Thanksgiving Dinners

Thanksgiving Dinners

Local restaurants in Youngstown & Mahoning County are offering dine-in options and carryout dinners this Thanksgiving 2023. Contact each restaurant directly to make reservations or place your order. Pick-up days and times vary.

Dine-In Thanksgiving Day

Cafe 422 
8586 South Ave., Boardman, 330-629-2422

Café 422 in Boardman will be open for dine-in from 12:00pm-4:00pm on Thanksgiving Day. Call 330-629-2422 to make your reservations.


Waypoint 4180 – Thanksgiving Grand Buffet
4180 Westford Place, Canfield, 330-286-3864

Thursday, November 23, one seating: noon to 4:00pm. Call 330-533-6692 by November 20 at 2:00pm. Featuring a carving station with roasted turkey; Waypoint salad, classic Caesar salad, assorted bread board, butter crumb haddock, eye of round with au jus, glazed ham with pineapple, red skin mashed potatoes, buttered whole kernel corn, traditional bread dressing, green bean casserole, baked sweet potato casserole, assorted desserts, coffee, tea, iced tea, soft drinks, and a cash bar. Adults $45, kids 12 & under $20, kids 6 & under free. Plus tax and gratuity.



Carryout Thanksgiving Dinner

Angenetta’s Restaurant
64 Cardinal Drive, Canfield, 330-533-6090

Place your Thanksgiving orders by Saturday, November 18. Pick up will be Wednesday, November 22. Their Thanksgiving Menu includes whole turkey ($7.99/lb. – 10# serves 4-6, 15# serves 6-10, 20# serves 8-12) with housemade stuffing inside turkey and served with gravy on the side. Sides (half-pan and full pan) are available of candied yams, mashed potatoes, bread stuffing, green beans, and corn. You can also order Tony’s Bread, fresh cranberries, and wedding soup. Desserts are also available.


Another Round Bar and Grille – Thanksgiving Carry Out Menu
625 E. Western Reserve Rd., Poland, 330-758-3317

Another Round Bar and Grille will be offering Thanksgiving Dinners for carry out. Preorders will be taken through Saturday, November 18. Pick up will be on Wednesday, November 22 from 12:00pm-4:00pm. Call 330-758-3317. For menu, visit the Another Round Bar and Grille Facebook page.


Jeff Chrystal Catering – Thanksgiving Dinner
2315 Belmont Ave., Youngstown, 330-743-8062

Orders must be placed in advance by November 19 and can be picked up on Thanksgiving Day between 10:30am and 3:00pm at 2315 Belmont Avenue. Call 330-743-8062 to place your order. Dinners to Go: Cherry wood spit or slow roasted turkey, sage stuffing, whipped potatoes with pan sauce, steamed vegetables, candied yams, cranberry sauce, salad with vinaigrette, homemade bread, and pumpkin pie. Large feeds 12-14 guests – $460.00; Small feeds 6-8 guests – $375.00. Individual Dinners: Roasted turkey breast, whipped potatoes with pan sauce, sage stuffing, vegetable medley, candied yams, cranberry sauce, garden salad with vinaigrette, homemade bread, and slice of pumpkin pie. $29.50 per dinner. Whole pies and homemade loaves of bread available.


Michael Alberini’s – Thanksgiving Family Style
1140 Boardman-Poland Rd., Poland, 330-965-2524

Michael Alberini’s is offering a full course dinner for pre-order, ready to heat and eat. All orders must be placed by Sunday, November 19 by 8:00pm. Pick up on November 22 between 2:00pm-9:00pm. For menu, visit the Michael Alberini’s Facebook page.


Napa Grocery
4350 Boardman-Canfield Rd., Canfield, 330-286-3136

Let Napa Grocery cook Thanksgiving dinner for you. Their Thanksgiving Feast includes sliced turkey breast, mashed potatoes, sausage stuffing, green beans with Pancetta, turkey gravy, house made cranberry sauce, Focaccia, tossed salad with vinaigrette, and pumpkin pie. Feed 6-8 people for $179, or 12-16 people for $339. Add ons available. Place orders by November 15, pick-up November 22 from 5-7pm.


The Vineyards at Pine Lake
14101 Market Street, Columbiana, 330-549-0195

The Vineyards at Pine Lake is offering catering for Thanksgiving Day. Pick-up times are November 23 at 10:00am and 10:30am. Price is $200 and serves 8 people. Menu includes house salad with rolls, turkey, creamy mashed potatoes and gravy, buttered corn or green beans, stuffing, and pumpkin pie.



Homemade Pies & Treats

Bake Me Treats
16 S. Main St., Poland, 234-254-4005

Brownie bites, buttercream pumpkin cutout cookies, pumpkin cheesecake mousse brownies, pumpkin eclairs, macarons, pumpkin pecan pie, and Thanksgiving decorated cupcakes are available. Call for preorder/pick-up information.


White House Fruit Farm
9249 State Route 62, Canfield, 330-533-4161

Your Thanksgiving Feast isn’t complete without dessert and you can order pies from White House Fruit Farm. They offer apple, pumpkin, pecan, cherry, fruits of the forest, and many more. Visit the White House Fruit Farm website to view all their options.


Listing last updated 11/08/2023